In need of a 250 word response/discussion to each of the following forum posts. Agreement/disagreement/and/or continuing the discussion.
Original forum discussion/topic post is as follows:
This week we will examine Post-traumatic Stress Disorder. The United States Government Accountability Office reviewed Department of Defense (DOD) data on service members separated for misconduct. The study found that over 60% of those service members had been diagnosed with a mental illness within two years prior to separation.
A brief video about the report:
https://www.usatoday.com/videos/news/nation/2017/0…
The report can be found here:
United States Government Accountability Office. (2017, May 26). Actions needed to ensure post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury are considered in misconduct Separations. Retrieved from http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-17-260
In this forum, please address the following:
Forum post response #1
What is the main purpose of diagnosis? Therapists use information gathered from interviews, tests, and observations to create a picture of the factors that may be causing and/or maintaining a client’s mental issues (Comer, 2014, p. 84). This clinical picture, including assessment data, can then be used in making a diagnosis. The main purpose of a diagnosis is the determination of whether or not a person’s psychological problems can be ascribed to a particular disorder. Diagnosis helps a therapist to form ideas about possible disorders (Comer, 2014, p. 84).
Ethical issues in diagnosis include possible labeling, label stigmatization, errant conclusions or diagnoses, possible inaccuracy of client/family symptom self-report, and any biases the clinician may hold which could affect accuracy of diagnosis (Comer, 2014, p. 88-89). Because the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) (American Psychiatric Association, 2013) lists approximately 400 disorders, accuracy is vital to the diagnostic process.
Differential diagnosis is a term for listing all possible disorders a client may have (Morrison, 2014, p. 5). Morrison (2014, p. 14) cites a 23-year-old male with hallucinations. A few of the possible diagnoses include psychotic depression, medication toxicity, mania, schizophrenia, alcohol misuse, and relevant medical conditions, such as epilepsy and brain tumor or injury (Morrison, 2014, p. 14). Morrison (2014, p. 16) suggests using a diagnostic safety hierarchy in which the top level contains conditions which need urgent treatment, the lower level contains conditions which are unlikely to be affected by treatment, and all other conditions in the center.
If an agency required an immediate diagnosis, I probably would not work there to begin with. If I discovered this policy after I joined the agency, I would move my practice elsewhere, after ensuring my clients’ welfare. The ethical concerns listed above should always be a part of the diagnostic process. Inaccurately labeling a client can cause harm, and initial impressions may incorrectly inform a diagnosis.
Diagnostic challenges in the military are most heavily seen in the separation process. The information in the United States Government Accountability Office (USGAO) (2017) class reading highlighted the ways that military branch policy may differ from those of the Department of Defense (DOD). When the appropriate assessment measures are not used to test for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) (Comer, 2014, 144-145), a military member may be subject to misconduct charges or dishonorable discharge (USGAO, 2017). This is notable because PTSD prevalence is higher in military members than in the general public (10-20% for the former compared to 8% for the latter) and assessing members for possible PTSD prior to separation allows for government mental health support and effective treatment methods (USGAO, 2017). PTSD has been around for centuries. It was referred to as shell shock during WWI and combat fatigue during WWII. Many military members experience serious psychological symptoms post-combat. Approximately 29% of male and female participants in Vietnam experienced acute or post-traumatic symptoms (Comer, 2014, p. 144). Another 22% experienced some stress symptoms and currently 10% of Vietnam veterans still experience PTSD symptoms, including flashbacks, night terrors, and nightmares (Comer, 2014, p. 145). There is a similar pattern for 20% of returning Afghanistan and Iraq war veterans. The most disheartening fact I discovered was that multiple deployments increase the possibility of severe PTSD by 50% (Comer, 2014, p. 145).
Diagnostic accuracy is important. Test and assess everything. Use differential diagnoses. Leave nothing to chance. This is a person who needs help. Find the safest most appropriate solution and do no harm in the process.
Forum post response #2
The main purpose of the diagnosis is so that the individual would feel better of course. People who has PTSD does not feel okay. With its side effects, it is important that cure is recommended. PTSD side effects include detachment, anxiety, depression, nightmares, agitation, hostility, not wanting to sleep due to fear, self-destruction behavior, mistrust, guilt, loss of interest and unwanted memories that lead to the trauma.
Ethical issue includes having trust and believe that one would recover from the shock or trauma is a concern. Another ethical issue is being able to keep a promise that one would stop being potentially in a shock due to a resultant situation of war or so. Having concern for others is another one; knowing that the diagnosis will boost the social life with others is a good idea.
Differential diagnosis refers to the act of differentiating between two or more conditions which was found to have similar signs and symptoms. With this fact, it is hard to differentiate during curing procedure because of the fact that most PTSD sicknesses symptoms comes with similar traumas. For example, if the procedure was to cure reoccurring symptoms of hostility, it could be that there were also depression problems that was not noticed due to differentiation in diagnosis. This requires attention as well.
Initially, I would do a check up introduction and overview of the signs and symptoms in other to decide on what treatment options to give. Then, I would formulate a treatment plan accordingly by asking these questions: how do you feel after you the accidental trauma? With this question, I expect lots of answers such as: I feel depressed and anxious, I feel sleepless and scared, I have fear that someone will get me bad, etc. I would formulate the treatment plan as followed:
The one challenge I know is that what if the military personal would get deployed again, maybe their symptoms would get back to them. The most symptom is the feeling of fear about dying. It is therefore important to pay attention to the military personnel’s who are having combat fear.
Forum post response #3